Honest BoxyCharm Review: Is it worth it?

Spread the love

I will admit that I love subscription boxes. It’s always fun to receive something new in the mail every month. Maybe it’s because it feels like Christmas morning opening up a fresh package or maybe it’s because subscription boxes normally have products that you’ve never used before and its fun sampling products that you’ve never tried. 

When I first discovered BoxyCharm Subscription Box  I was very impressed that in every box you receive 4-5 full-sized products worth over $100 from well-known brands (such as Smashbox, Tarte and Wander Beauty) and from brands that are new and upcoming. I also found out that they try to include brands and products that are cruelty-free which is something that I really love!

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, I will earn a small compensation if you make a purchase. ALL opinions are on my own.

Back in May of 2018 I emailed BoxyCharm about wanting to try out their Subscription Box to give my honest review to you guys.

When the mail man showed up to drop off my first BoxyCharm box, I couldn’t contain my excitement I was smiling and eagerly waiting like a little kid for candy.  Each of the products in my first box were from brands that I was unfamiliar with but I didn’t mind. My first box came with a variety of items such as: primer, makeup brushes, highlighter and contour kit, liquid lipstick and liquid eyeliner. I was very impressed it was almost enough different products for me to create a whole new look . 

This was the first box I recieved 

BoxyCharm’s monthly subscription box costs $21/month which I think is pretty affordable compared to many subscription boxes such as IPSY  which costs $10/month for 5 sample sized products. 

So far I have received a total of 5 boxes and I loved mostly all products in each box. Many of you may ask what if I get products that I won’t use or don’t like? (Which I think will rarely happen) But if you do get a product that you don’t like you can always resell it on an app or Facebook marketplace or you could re-gift it during the holidays/special occasions. 


  • 4-5 Full Sized Products
  • Cruelty-Free Brands and Products
  • Good Quality Makeup for only $21/month


  • I truly couldn’t find anything that I disliked about it. 


Overall I truly think that BoxyCharm Subscription Box  is best choice when trying to decide on the perfect makeup subscription box for yourself or someone else. I was honestly impressed by how well that I liked it and how good of quality the makeup was. I even found some new makeup brands that I really liked.  It would be a great gift during the holidays or even as a birthday gift. 

Below is more photos of all the boxes that I received. 

Questions For you:

  1. Have you ever tried BoxyCharm?
  2. What is your favorite Cruelty-Free Beauty Brand?
  3. What is your favorite Beauty Product?

13 thoughts on “Honest BoxyCharm Review: Is it worth it?

  1. I must say that i personally i’m not a fan of monthly boxes because for what i’ve seen it isn’t worth it but now that i’ve seen your past boxes i’m interested. I love eyeshadow palettes so it got me. Great Post 🙂

    1. I used to not be a fan of monthly boxes but then I signed up for FabFitFun and it was fun for awhile but then I started getting things that I’d never use. I’m glad BoxyCharm sends products that are worth it! Thank you for reading 🙂

    1. Yes! I absolutely love getting Subscription boxes in the mail! That’s one of my favorite things 🙂

  2. I’ve never tried Boxy Charm and above all I’ve never tried subscription boxes, but reading your post I got an absurd curiosity to try them!

    1. I have a couple Subscription boxes but BoxyCharm is my new favorite! You should totally try one! 🙂

  3. It looks like you got some great goodies! I haven’t subscribed to Boxy Charm, but I’m been subscribed to ipsy for about 4 years and love it!

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: